Seems to be a problem with your printer. Mine is laser HP and is the same. Is good for documents, but not pictures.
I’s use the 10mb image, either from the download (I never did that so I dunno) or from the forum here:
https://forum.enlightenedstates.com/t/nfts-original-image-download/38464
What came as 261kb was a preview. On Phantom Wallet, you can choose to “view on Solscan” or smth like that. And then under the image (in Solscan page), there is a “view original” button. Which is the image uploaded on that thread.
I’d definitely use an original one over a preview or the wallet thumbnail.